Biases in STEM still prevalent according to new survey

Recruitment bias against race, age and gender continues to prevent STEM professionals who have had a career break return to employment, according to a new survey by STEM Returners.

The STEM Returners Index 2023, published in National Inclusion Week, showed women trying to return to the engineering industry after a career break are more likely to experience recruitment bias than men.

Nearly 24% of women said they felt they have personally experienced bias in recruitment processes due to their gender compared to nine percent of men.

In the survey, professionals from minority ethnic backgrounds represented 39% of candidates attempting to return to work in 2023. They were twice as likely as all other ethnic groups 34% versus an average of 17% to feel they have experienced bias in a recruitment process related to race or ethnicity.

Have you read?
Xodus joins STEM Returners to address energy transition skills gap
myenergi co-founder named as inspirational woman in STEM

An average of 29% of men and 25% of women said they felt they have personally experienced bias in recruitment processes due to their age. As a result, 30% of returners say their personal confidence has been affected by the recruitment challenges they face, and their low confidence remains a barrier.

The Index asked more than 1,000 STEM professionals on a career break a range of questions to understand their experiences of trying to re-enter the STEM sector.

However, the latest results show some progress. In 2022, 29% of women said they felt bias due to their gender, more than this year and overall, 38% of returners felt they had experienced bias in a recruitment process, compared to 33% this year.

In 2022, 65% of participants said they found the process of getting back to work difficult or very difficult, but this year that number decreased to 51% of participants.

Natalie Desty, founder and director of STEM Returners, said: “For the first year since we launched the STEM Returners Index, we have seen that candidates are finding it slightly easier to return to work than they were this time last year. This is positive news but there are still too many people finding it an uphill battle."

She added, “Women and professionals from minority ethnic backgrounds still face a significant disadvantage when attempting to return. People from minority ethnic backgrounds were 50% percent more likely than white British candidates to say they were finding the process of returning ‘very difficult’. This has to change. Additionally, we are seeing people who have moved to the UK from overseas are finding it difficult to transfer their international skills and experience to UK positions."

In the survey, only 12% of career breakers stop working out of personal choice. Caring for children and family members was the primary reason for a career break for 44% of respondents. 36% of women said they feel they have personally experienced bias in recruitment processes due to childcare responsibilities compared to 8% of men, according to the results.

Despite 86% of respondents having career breaks lasting less than five years, 38% of candidates felt they have received bias related to lack of recent experience, signalling there is a perception that a break leads to a deterioration of skills.

Helping professionals return

When asked if they would have preferred to return to work through a supported returners programme, 40% of returners said yes.

Despite the clear need for structured return to work programmes, only 21% had seen one, and only 16% had returned to work via this route – underlining the need for more STEM employers to think seriously about diversifying their approach to recruitment.

Elizabeth Chikwanha-Mavengano had 14 years of engineering experience in Zimbabwe and South Africa including studying for a masters in civil engineering, before moving to the UK in 2023. She applied for several structural engineering roles but found it challenging to get an interview. She discovered STEM Returners and completed a programme with Amey Consulting after which she accepted a permanent role as a project manager, based in Sheffield.

She said: “I had lots of mining experience but there are no mines in the UK; I had a senior role in South Africa but without the UK experience, companies did not want to employ me, so I opted for junior roles, but I wasn’t familiar with some of the software, so I didn’t get anywhere."

Partnering with STEM organisations to run paid, short-term returner programmes, STEM Returners has supported and mentored more than 400 returners back into permanent roles.

STEM Returners is also part of the STEM ReCharge programme, which is funded by the Government’s Equality Hub, which is delivering free of charge return to work career coaching, job skills training and sector-specific upskilling and mentoring designed to support parents and carers in the midlands and the north of England.

The report is available to view here.